An Ethical Dilemma within the Army Essays - 1438 Words

Standards or Numbers: An Ethical Dilemma Every organization, both large and small, will typically have a well-defined set of values that they wish to espouse. This is the template for a successful, trained work force. These values will guide individuals during the decision-making processes that they will encounter. This blue print helps to ensure the integrity of the company and the individual, as well. Our Army today is no different. We can find our values and creeds everywhere we turn. One quick trip to a company or battalion headquarters will yield all the information a Soldier ever needs to assist them in making ethical choices. We hang posters touting the seven Army values on every wall. Units will prominently display the†¦show more content†¦We have an ethical dilemma today created by shortages that encourage us to abandon or lower standards in an effort to fill our ranks. The Battle of the â€Å"Bulge† In 2003, I was witness to this ethical dilemma first hand. I, like so many of my peers, was preparing for an upcoming deployment. There were unfilled positions within the battalion to be sure. Noncommissioned Officers (NCOs) struggled with plans to ensure a successful rotation despite this. However, at no time did a single NCO ever consider just simply stopping a pending chapter to fill a position. Nevertheless, this was our guidance for every case that concerned an overweight Soldier. That one broad ranging directive from the brigade immediately placed every NCO into an ethical dilemma. The brigade expected us to ignore the Army standards so that we could implement a quick fix solution to our problems. You have to consider for a moment the serious nature of this action. When we deploy, we rely on the person to our left and right. The profession of arms is one that requires all to do their part. Combat, by nature, is a physical, difficult, and demanding task. A person’s very life may depend on the actions of those around him or her. Ask any Soldier pulled from the vehicle hit by an improvised explosive device if that is true or not. You must have personnel on whom you can rely. The actions and directions from the brigade forced us to accept people who may beShow MoreRelatedAbuse of Authority Essay1274 Words   |  6 PagesIf Soldiers and leaders adhered to the Army Values and the Leadership Requirements Model, many ethical dilemmas that Noncommissioned Officers face on a daily basis would not occur. In the Army today, Soldiers constantly discuss values and leadership, unfortunately not everyone takes them seriously. The abuse of authority and command influence somet imes displayed by leaders puts subordinates into ethical dilemmas. Often, command influence will challenge the Loyalty, Duty, Respect, and Honor valuesRead MoreThe Ethical Dilemma Of `` Enemy At The Gates 1205 Words   |  5 Pagesan order. Is it ethical to order to shoot your own troops without a court? Or are we facing an ethical dilemma of uncertainty? Today I want to talk about ethical side of making difficult decisions. I want to talk about most controversial Stalin’s order in WW2, infamous order #227, also known as: Not a step back! I will prove that despite all controversy around this decision, during that period Stalin was an ethical leader. I want to talk how other people fall into ethical dilemma of uncertainty whenRead More1.1.Objective Evaluation Of All Available Options. According1626 Words   |  7 Pagesbears testimony to the fact that time and again large-scale disasters happened due to the lack of ethical standards of some leaders or the other. We come to know from his research that there are two approaches to handle ‘ethical dilemma’: 1) before deciding on the course of action, assess the practical consequences likely to follow and 2) whatever be the likely consequences, do what you consider ethical. The first school of thought argues that if there is no harm, there is no foul. The second claimsR ead MoreColonel (Col) Michael Steele’s Toxic Principles934 Words   |  4 Pagesorganizational core values. 3rd Brigade’s disassociated ethical subculture fostered a toxic environment which compromised both subordinate commanders and individual soldiers moral standards to various extents. Col Steele’s vague guidance concerning proper ethical behavior during the execution of high stress Counter-Insurgency (COIN) missions resulted in subordinates failing to conduct kinetic operations in accordance with established Army ethical standards. The military establishment shall rememberRead MoreThe Ethics Of Medical Appointments1532 Words   |  7 PagesToday the Army is an organization that closely manages every penny spent to avoid what it considers wasteful spending on inefficient practices. Across the board, within the scope of Army activities exist many practices that are wasteful and take money from other areas of necessity. Medical treatment by way of medica l appointments is one such process that has had to undergo a shift in practice as medical appointment failures have risen during intense budget constraints. As an Army major commandRead MoreThe Ethics Of Medical Appointments1583 Words   |  7 PagesToday the Army is an organization that closely manages every penny spent to avoid what it considers wasteful spending on inefficient practices. Across the board, within the scope of Army activities exist many practices that are wasteful and take money from other areas of necessity. Medical treatment by way of medical appointments is one such process that has had to undergo a shift in practice as medical appointment failures have risen during intense budget constraints. As an Army major commandRead MoreA Historical Event Involving An Ethical Challenge Essay1327 Words   |  6 PagesThis has inspired the U.S. Army to emphasize character development prior to a unit’s deployment as a means of preparing soldiers for ethical chall enges and to ensure that those soldiers demonstrate behaviors that align with the U.S. Army’s organizational values. This paper will explore the importance of ethical leadership, examine a historical event involving an ethical challenge, and discuss character development methods that prepare soldiers to address future ethical challenges with character,Read MoreSetting The Stage For The Events That Took Place1487 Words   |  6 Pagesmany biases and facts due to the worldwide coverage and unraveling topics that are still surfacing almost four (4) years later. In order to fully piece together the events that took place and offer an analytical discussion based on legal and ethical dilemmas, one must approach the topic without bias and offer all aspects of the topic. Known as the â€Å"biggest leak of government secrets in history† (Breslow, 2014, para. 2), Edward Snowden, a former National Security Agency (NSA) contractor, contactedRead MoreValues Based Decision-Making Essay1372 Words   |  6 Pagesirresponsible decision can damage the trust that is the basis of my marriage. In my job as an Army officer I must make responsible decisions. I have a responsibility to my nation, soldiers, and their families to make good decisions. Flawed, irresponsible decisions in my profession could cause death, harm, or an international incident. Being a responsible leader leads to trust, honor, and loyalty within an organization, values that are consistent with and essential for military service (FritzscheRead MoreEssay about Values Based Decision-Making1416 Words   |  6 Pagesirresponsible decision can damage the trust that is the basis of my marriage. In my job as an Army officer I must make responsible decisions. I have a responsibility to my nation, soldiers, and their families to make good decisions. Flawed, irresponsible decisions in my profession could cause death, harm, or an international incident. Being a responsible leader leads to trust, honor, a nd loyalty within an organization, values that are consistent with and essential for military service (Fritzsche